Two
types of restrictions
Reincarnation
- or more properly, rebirth - is one basic tenet of Buddhism,
and this includes rebirth of humans as other animals,
and vice-versa. As a result, many Buddhists do not kill
animals, and many also do not eat meat. Other common reasons
cited are that killing animals and/or eating their meat
are a violation of the Five Precepts and bad for one's
own karma, and because of a compassion for other animals.
Many vegetarian Buddhists are not vegan, but for those
who are vegan, such beliefs are often due to objections
about the circumstances in which the animals producing
products such as milk and eggs are raised.
Some
Mahayana Buddhists in China and Vietnam also avoid eating
strong-smelling plants such as onion, garlic, chives,
shallot, and leek, and refer to these as wu hun (??, "Five
Spices"). The theory behind this Buddhist dietary
restriction is that these vegetables have strong flavours
which are supposed to excite the senses and thus represent
a burden to Buddhists seeking to control their desires.
Another explanation is that these are all root crops,
and harvesting them requires killing organisms in the
soil. It is unclear which is the correct explanation,
if indeed there is one.
Only
for some Buddhists
There
are no universally agreed-upon rules for permitted and
unpermitted foods in Buddhism. In some regions, it's common
for monks to eat no meat, but for the laity to, or for
the laity to abstain when they visit a monastery. But
even some Buddhist monks will eat meat. A majority of
Buddhist traditions believe the Buddha himself taught
that food offered as charity to monks and nuns should
not be refused, unless the killing was done specifically
for the monks and nuns. However, other traditions believe
this to be inaccurate, and that the Buddha was strictly
vegetarian. It is also common for Buddhists in some regions
to believe that vegetarianism is better for their karma
than eating meat, but to eat meat anyway and consider
it something of a bad habit, and in other areas, such
as Japan, vegetarianism and avoidance of wu hun foods
are not a large part of Buddhism.
It
is worth noting when debating the details of the Buddha's
teachings that there existed no written language in India
at the time of the historical Buddha. Furthermore, it
is widely believed and accepted (if not wholly accepted)
that the Buddha's final words were "Be a light unto
thyself". The combination of these two facts/beliefs
have lead to a general agreement that it is more important
for the individual to make their choices along the path
for themselves. Vegetarianism is thus one of the most
controversial aspects of Buddhism, with the teachings
of compassion and Karma being the only real guides for
the practitioner. The conflicting aspects of compassion,
being the humility to accept whatever is offered while
simultaneously not wanting to cause suffering unto sentient
beings, is not likely to be easily resolved.
Common
sources for Buddhist foods
Buddhist
vegetarian chefs have become extremely creative in imitating
meat using gluten, tofu, agar, and other plant products.
Some of their recipes are the oldest and most-refined
versions of meat-analogues in the world. Soy and pressed
wheat gluten (seitan, or wheat-meat) are very versatile
materials, because they can be manufactured into various
shapes and textures, and they absorb flavourings, whilst
having very little flavour of their own. With the proper
seasonings, they can mimic various kinds of meat quite
closely.
Some
of these Buddhist vegetarian chefs are in the many monasteries
which serve mock-meat (and sometimes non-wu hun) dishes
to the monks and visitors, including the public.
Many
Buddhist restaurants also serve vegetarian and/or non-wu
hun dishes. Some Buddhists eat vegetarian only once per
month or on special occasions such as annual visits to
the ancestor's graves. To cater to this type of customer,
as well as vegetarians, the menu of a Buddhist vegetarian
restaurant usually shows no difference from a typical
Chinese or far-Eastern restaurant, except that it is a
full menu of "meat" dishes made using meat analogues.
|